Hospitals overcharging Patients under Cashless Claims is under the media buzz since a few days.
Here is a quick post which reasons why Hospitals overcharge Cashless Claims:
No Contracted Rates with Hospitals:
TPAs do not have contract binding rates (treatment-wise) with Hospitals in their network. Globally, TPAs contract treatment-wise rates with each Hospital in their network. Treatment wise fixed rates would remove the disparities and anomalies that Hospitals currently enjoy. The core of the issue is TPAs lack negotiation power with Hospitals.
Why do TPAs lack negotiating power?
In India, more than 70% of the total hospital billing is still out-of-pocket and not through Insurance Companies or TPAs. Hospitals are overflowing with patients and therefore don’t depend on TPAs for their revenues. (Imagine a 100 employee TPA bidding to negotiate with a Hinduja, Apollo, Fortis or an Escorts?)
1). Insurance Companies under demands from Large Corporate Customers to list a large hospital, unconditionally pressure, TPAs to include certain hospitals into their network, without rates.
2). Add to this, TPAs are also under pressure to have a large and geographically wide list of close to 3500-4000 hospitals under their network. Due to such a large spread of hospital payments in the network, they cannot guarantee revenue to hospitals, which is the trump card for Health Claims Administrators worldwide.
3). Every division of a Government Insurance Company in a bid to offer the option of a TPA to large customers, use services of 6-8 TPAs. Customers are therefore spread across larger no. of TPAs.
4). Customers (especially Corporate/Group) want to decide their hospital. TPAs currently don’t take the healthcare responsibility of recommending hospitals. Hospitals therefore get 'business' on the decision of the consumer and not the administrator.
Delayed payments to Hospitals:
This is the justification each hospital will give. Insurance Companies (mostly Govt. and some Private) due to their internal deep rooted inefficiencies have been guilty of delaying payments to TPAs. TPAs being small sized companies depend on funding from Insurance companies and therefore in turn delay payments of the Hospitals. Some Hospitals in need of liquid cash, have been known to discount their authorized cashless claims with Banks and Financial Institutions, ofcourse at a cost. Every Hospital would be ready to reduce their costs if they are committed to payments in say, 30 days.
Recently a new Insurance company has been sucessful in negotiating better rates with Hospitals on the contracted committments to pay on time, with interest penalties.
Lack of Uniform Grading:
There is no regulating apex body or uniform grading of hospitals in India, which makes contracting of rates with Hospitals all the more subjective and unscientific. Rates charges are merely based on location and popularity and not on the quality and consistency of the care and treatment.
Apart from the recent kneejerk delisting/reduction in number of hospitals (to ones which agree to contracted rates), by Insurance companies, here are some solutions our experts recommend.
1). Health Insurance premiums have grown by 10 times in 5 years. Insurance companies should work towards increasing their negotiating capabilities with Hospitals, by bringing revenue dynamics into picture.
2). Govt. Insurance Companies should reduce the fragmented way in which it engages TPAs. This will bring more business to lesser no. of TPAs, and hence bring administrative and financial control on claims.
3). Insurance Companies should lobby with the Central Government and Ministy of Health and Welfare to bring in an apex body which enables self regulation and grading of Hospitals and other Healthcare providers.
4). Selection of Hospital Network should be based on quality of Healthcare. Like the "gatekeeper model" in the west, TPAs should be empowered to take responsibility of healthcare beyond negotiation of rates. They should be in a position to recommend the healthcare provider to the customer.
5). Insurance Companies and TPAs should take into account demography and economics and scientifically fix a schedule of treatment-wise limits for cashless claims, in its policy condition.This way, Insurance Companies or TPAs would pay upto the limit and leave negotiation of the amount charged over the limit to the Customer.
Do let us know if you have any questions or feedback. Write to Medimanage @ email [at] medimanage [dot] com.
7. January 2011, 20:09
I had gone through your article, "Why do hospitals overcharge cashless health insurance claims?"
Reply to that an idea to centralized empanelment/depanelmant of hospitals through a dedicated agency or any one serviced TPA. that willl helpful in fraud control + De-Panel fear in hospitals, that any mal-practice will de-panel us & we have to loose ~35% of our revenues.
8. March 2011, 10:47
When the hospital knows the patient has insurance, they start salivating like a DOG !!! And think we will earn good amount from the insurance company through the patient. This is what I have experienced in my life. Medicals/Doctors are the MOST currpt in this country and they do not have humanity which is in contrast to their OATH they take when they start their career.